Volkswacht Bodensee - EU unveils 2040 climate targets in political tightrope act

The 27-nation European Union has pledged to be carbon neutral by 2050, and set a first interim target for 2030: to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 55 percent compared with 1990 levels.

For the next milestone, 2040, working documents suggest the European Commission will aim for a net drop of 90 percent -- which would mean roughly the same pace of cuts as it has pledged for 2020-2030.

But this time around, Brussels has to factor in growing discontent -- illustrated by the farmer protests of recent weeks -- over the social and economic impact of its much-vaunted Green Deal.

After successfully tackling the green transition in transport, energy and industry, the Green Deal has found itself on a collision course with the farming world -- and its champions in the European Parliament.

Across Europe, on the right of the political spectrum, there is an increasingly vocal backlash to the sweeping set of policies aimed at meeting the bloc's climate targets, and several leaders in the bloc are now calling for a "pause" in new environmental rules.

The EU's climate commissioner, Wopke Hoekstra, last month warned the bloc needed to keep standing "on two legs" -- with its climate ambition on one side, and on the other "making sure our businesses stay competitive, there is a just transition."

- 'Leave no one behind'-

Striking that balance is at the heart of a joint letter to Brussels, sent by 11 states including France, Germany and Spain, and seen by AFP.

Together they urge the commission to set an "ambitious EU climate target" for 2040.

But the states also call for a "fair and just transition," that should "leave no one behind, especially the most vulnerable citizens".

With far-right and nationalist parties predicted to make significant gains in June's European elections, the climate debate has turned politically explosive.

The EU's executive arm was obligated to submit new post-2030 climate projections within six months of December's COP28 climate conference.

The targets laid out on Tuesday will be a simple recommendation.

But the next European Commission, to be appointed after the elections, will be tasked with turning it into legislation for member states and EU lawmakers to consider ahead of next year's COP30 climate conference.

The bloc's 2040 targets are expected to rely in part on the capture and storage of ambitious volumes of carbon dioxide -- incensing campaigners who criticise the technologies as untested and want to see gross emissions cut pledges instead.

But even so, the plan would require a sizeable effort from every sector of the economy -- from power generation to farming, which accounts for 11 percent of EU emissions.

- 'Very ambitious' -

Pascal Canfin, chair of the European Parliament's environment committee, doubts the bloc will need a second Green Deal.

From now until 2030, he says, "the job is done," with a "massive transformation" of society already underway.

But "if we don't keep moving, we won't meet the end target," he warned.

"One of the issues at stake in this election is whether or not we pursue the Green Deal."

For Canfin, Tuesday's target announcement is also a way to force the EU's politicians to show their colours on the climate issue.

Some of the strongest resistance to tougher environmental action is coming from the centre-right European People's Party (EPP) -- from which European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen hails.

The EPP's Peter Liese says a more cautious stance is justified.

"It's easy to fix a figure," he said, but as the bloc has been implementing its existing 2030 target, "we see more and more how ambitious it is."

"It's more difficult to really make the transition happen in industry and also with the citizens."

Liese considers a 90-percent emissions cut to be a "very ambitious" target for 2040, and stresses the need for "the right conditions, the right policy framework."

"We need to take people along," he said, advocating targeted help for low-income families for whom, for instance, investing in an electric car may be entirely out of reach.

On that front, Elisa Giannelli, of the E3G climate advocacy group, had a similar message, urging the EU to keep the social impact of its climate policies front of mind.

"Getting this wrong," she said, "would allow conservative and populist voices to set the direction of the next steps."

G.Frei--VB