Volkswacht Bodensee - South Africa’s Economic Shift: Why Services Must Lead Job Creation Beyond Manufacturing

NYSE - LSE
RBGPF 0% 75.65 $
RELX -0.17% 40.44 $
RYCEF 0.85% 17.74 $
CMSC -0.73% 19.14 $
BCC -1.54% 66.37 $
CMSD -0.33% 18.86 $
RIO -3.62% 80.05 $
NGG -0.01% 84.28 $
BCE 3.16% 22.13 $
VOD -0.39% 15.31 $
BTI 0.35% 62.11 $
GSK -0.08% 50.41 $
JRI -1.8% 11.09 $
AZN -0.23% 184.02 $
BP -1.74% 44.92 $
South Africa’s Economic Shift: Why Services Must Lead Job Creation Beyond Manufacturing
South Africa’s Economic Shift: Why Services Must Lead Job Creation Beyond Manufacturing

South Africa’s Economic Shift: Why Services Must Lead Job Creation Beyond Manufacturing

South Africa is facing a critical juncture in its economic recovery, with new research indicating that the traditional reliance on manufacturing-led growth is no longer viable. Calum Hamilton and Emmanuel Mensah argue that policymakers must pivot toward upgrading the services sector to address the country’s stalled productivity and create sustainable employment opportunities for the future.

Text size:

South Africa’s economy is at a crossroads, requiring a fundamental rethinking of how jobs are created and productivity is sustained. According to new research by Calum Hamilton and Emmanuel Mensah, the long-held belief that reviving manufacturing will automatically solve the country’s employment crisis overlooks a deeper structural problem: the stagnation of overall productivity growth.

In a recent policy paper for Economic Research Southern Africa (Ersa), titled ‘The Structural Change Emergency in South Africa,’ Hamilton and Mensah argue that the debate over which sectors should lead the economy has missed the central issue. They contend that policymakers must address why productivity growth stalled and how to reverse that trend, rather than focusing solely on sectoral revival.

The researchers describe the decade from 2010 to 2019 as a period of negligible productivity growth, labeling it a “structural change emergency.” During this time, labor productivity in major sectors stagnated. Crucially, workers shifted on average from more productive sectors to less productive ones—a phenomenon economists term negative structural change. In healthy emerging economies, the opposite typically occurs, with labor moving toward higher-productivity activities.

This emergency was not isolated to a single region. The data shows that six of South Africa’s nine provinces recorded falling labor productivity during the 2010s. Negative structural change exacerbated the situation in eight of these provinces. Only the Western Cape escaped this trend, where the effect of structural change on productivity was negligible.

This period marked a sharp reversal from the 2000s, when labor productivity grew at a respectable average of about 2% per year. During that earlier decade, improvements in most major sectors were reinforced by positive structural change, as workers moved toward more productive activities. Mining was an exception to this general improvement.

There are now grounds for cautious optimism regarding recent trends. Since 2020, labor productivity growth has picked up to an average of 1% to 1.5% per year, and structural change has turned positive again. This modest recovery is balanced across provinces, with Gauteng lagging slightly behind the national trend.

However, Hamilton and Mensah warn that this recovery has specific limitations. It has been driven entirely by productivity growth in the services sector and a shift of workers toward service-based jobs. This dynamic differs significantly from the pre-2010s era. Manufacturing and other non-service industries have not recovered; in many cases, productivity in these sectors is falling faster in the 2020s than it did during the previous emergency decade.

A recovery led by the services sector is not inherently problematic. The concern lies in the fact that industry persistently drags down productivity growth in every province. This reality adds to growing doubts about whether South Africa can replicate the manufacturing-led development model associated with China and other successful East Asian economies.

While manufacturing accounted for approximately 10% of South African employment in 2024 and has historically been a key source of productivity gains, experts no longer view it as the sole route to development. Modern manufacturing has become increasingly capital-intensive, while services have become more tradeable and capable of generating productivity growth and economic transformation.

The authors emphasize that South Africa should not abandon manufacturing. However, policymakers must be realistic about its role in driving faster growth and creating jobs for less-skilled workers. The sector can no longer be expected to recreate the mass employment model of an earlier industrial era. Relieving manufacturing of the burden of mass job creation may allow technological progress in the sector to become a cause for optimism rather than concern.

Conversely, services have become increasingly tradeable and capable of generating productivity gains, opening new possibilities for growth through exports. However, a growing services sector does not automatically ensure a more productive economy, as productivity varies considerably across different service activities.

In South Africa, retail, wholesale, and hospitality sectors employ many people but have productivity levels well below the national average. Similarly, productivity in personal services, including domestic work and caregiving, is below average. While these jobs provide vital livelihoods, often when better alternatives are scarce, they are unlikely to transform the economy on their own.

South Africa’s challenge regarding services is twofold: raising productivity in large, growing sectors like retail, wholesale, and hospitality, and creating more jobs in higher-productivity services such as transport, finance, and business services. This process is known as “within-services upgrading.”

The researchers suggest four ways to raise productivity in existing services: helping more firms formalize, improving business capabilities, building better digital infrastructure, and encouraging stronger competition. They argue that industrial policy need not be confined solely to industry. Policy may need to focus mainly on services, recognizing that they will have to do more of the heavy lifting in employment while industry recovers its capacity to generate value.

Exports offer another avenue for growth. The authors estimate that exports account for 20% to 25% of South African output and jobs. However, these shares have remained broadly stable for decades, suggesting that established trading relationships may have reached their limits. Greater trade with other developing economies and within Africa could open new markets. Additionally, the growing ability to sell services internationally creates further possibilities.

Policymakers do not face a simple choice between reviving industry and embracing services; both have essential roles. Industry must stop holding back productivity growth, while services must create most of the new jobs at a higher average productivity than before. This requires helping workers move from less productive to more productive services.

A return to the balanced growth of the 2000s may no longer be possible in a fundamentally changed global environment. Regardless of where one lands in the manufacturing versus services debate, three things are clearly needed: halting industrial decline, upgrading services, and developing new export markets.

Hamilton and Mensah conclude that the structural change emergency may be over, but the recovery has a long way to go. The question is less about choosing between two broad sectors and more about how they can operate in harmony to drive sustainable economic development.

R.Braegger--VB